I want to begin today by thanking all of you for coming.
Melanie would have been surprised and pleased at the size
of this crowd. My family joins me in being extremely grateful
for your presence.
Young people are not supposed to die. And parents shouldn’t
have to bury a child. The cliché is that there
are no words of comfort at times like these. The cliché
is wrong. The scores of sympathy cards, many with thoughtful
notes, the stream of e-mails, the postings on the web
sites, the flowers, the food and the brief visits have
provided enormous comfort for me and my family.
I particularly want to thank the members of our extended
family who have provided so much loving support over the
last few weeks as we said goodbye to Lynda’s mother
Evelyn and prepared to say goodbye to Melanie. Thanks
especially to my son-in-law Sotiere who has been a model
for sons-in-law as he has supported our family. Sotiere
can not know our pain, but he knows we are in pain and
he has helped so much. He’s brought food and provided
shuttle service to and from the airport over the last
two months. And he has held my daughter Sharon when grief
has overwhelmed her.
Melanie and Alison, identical twins, were born in 1978.
Early on, almost as infants, we noticed that Alison seemed
to be the more cheerful of the two. Pictures taken during
their childhood usually showed a grinning Alison and what
we called then a more serious Melanie. By the time Melanie
was eight or nine years old, we knew that she had problems
of extreme shyness, anxiety and something we could not
name, but which a few years later was diagnosed as mixed
depression. As a teenager, she was hospitalized for oppositional
defiance, anxiety and depression.
Years of outpatient treatment followed, with superb
primary care from Dr. Kristine Diehl who fought so ferociously
to try to save Melanie’s life. Numerous psychiatrists,
psychologists, counselors and clinical social workers
all treated her at one time or another. Anxiolytics, antidepressants,
selective serotonin release inhibitors and the like were
prescribed. But these medications generally took days,
weeks or even months to take effect and by that time,
Melanie had already found something that worked far faster
and much more reliably -- alcohol. Somewhere around age
sixteen, Melanie began a serious love affair with alcohol
that was to last all the rest of her short life. That
affair included the usual life threatening injuries, hospitalizations,
brushes with the law, missed family celebrations and,
at the end, dropping out of college. After she reached
the legal age of majority, there was even less we were
able to do for her.
Those in the modeling community who, because of her
death, learned of Melanie’s alcoholism, were astonished.
But like a lot of alcoholics, Melanie could suspend her
drinking to keep commitments that were important to her,
and she so loved her modeling career.
On December 22nd of last year, Melanie, as a pedestrian,
was hit by a car. The car took her out at the knees, flipped
her onto the hood whereupon her face and shoulder broke
the windshield. Tossed into the air and over the car,
she landed on her head. Witnesses were sure she was dead.
Unconscious, she was taken to Christiana Hospital by ambulance,
where they saved her. She lived, dodging yet another bullet.
But maybe not. In addition to horrendous bruises and
a lot of pain and immobility, she had permanent knee damage,
some scars and something called post concussion syndrome.
This condition left her pupils dilated with resulting
photophobia, and it left her body possessed of bizarre
twitches and jerking motions. Most threateningly, she
experienced a deepening spiral of severe depression that
was heartbreaking to witness. And so her drinking worsened
dramatically, with benders and, ominously, binge drinking.
She had several episodes of getting really drunk, then
not passing out, but drinking more, a lot more. We tried
to get her institutionalized, but that is not easy if
an adult patient doesn’t want that kind of help.
On Saturday April 20th of this year, she headed out
for the evening with her sister Alison and Alison’s
boyfriend Mark. That afternoon, Lynda and I listened with
mixed emotions as she and her sister spent what seemed
to be hours bathing, laughing, giggling, applying makeup,
drying their hair and dressing. Emotions of joy, to match
their infectious excitement—they chattered like
monkeys. And dread, because Saturday nights, have not
been the best times for the Barber family. As they were
leaving, Melanie turned to her mother and said, loud enough
for me to hear, “Love you guys. Please don’t
worry about us.” And as has been true for at least
the last five years, we worried.
But the night was quiet for us: no phone calls, no police,
no loud noises, no one stumbling on the stairs, no bodies
falling over. And nothing at all the next morning. We
even went out and enjoyed a Sunday lunch at The Olive
Garden. Nothing, until the phone call came about three
in the afternoon, the phone call that changed our lives
forever.
Melanie had had too many drinks that Saturday night,
then went to a liquor store to buy some whiskey, then
to a friends house for more drinking. She ended the night,
as she often did, at Alison’s boyfriend’s
house, with everybody crashing about three in the morning.
But, as had become more common, Melanie got up after everyone
else slept and began drinking anew. Missing, according
to the police, were the contents of a half bottle of wine
and a whole bottle of whiskey. This massive amount of
alcohol readily passed through the lining of her stomach
and small intestine, quickly overwhelming her liver. Severe
central nervous system depression, narcosis, anesthesia,
respiratory arrest, massive organ failure and death. We
lost her. And, she is gone forever.
I have six reasons why I decided to tell this awful
story: First, I thought that maybe if I wrote it down
and said it out loud, I might understand it. We will see.
Second, I wanted to squelch some ugly, hurtful rumors
circulating here in Wilmington, in the modeling, photography
and publishing communities and on the internet. The way
she actually died was bad enough. Third, I wanted those
of you who did not know us well to know that we did all
under God’s heaven to save her over the years. Forth,
I wanted two people, I’m very fond of, who were
with her when she died, to know that when she stopped
breathing, a team of professional paramedics with all
the right equipment would not have likely saved her. By
the time they knew something was wrong, called the paramedics
and called home for my help, she had been dead for hours.
Fifth, I wanted all her family and friends to know that
she felt nothing, she just forgot to breathe and never
felt the discomfort of oxygen depravation. Sixth and lastly,
I hoped that anyone in this audience who has a problem
similar to Melanie’s will get the help they need
so that they don’t cause the anguish and sorrow
Melanie’s death has brought to her friends and family.
She was so careless with her life, something we cared
so much about.
And so she died.
But the Melanie who lives on in our hearts was so much
more than that sad story. The difficulties I just related
took up so little of the life she lived and the life we
remember.
Her mother remembers a kind and loving daughter who
told her Mom everything, including things I certainly
didn’t want to know about. Her sister Sharon remembers
a little sister who acted as confidant, friend and cheerleader.
Her sister Carrie remembers a young lady she hoped to
know better as that sister became an adult. Alison, whose
closeness to Melanie makes her loss incalculable, remembers
a soul mate to whom she will now dedicate the rest of
her life. Pray for Alison. Her niece Jackie remembers
how Melanie liked playing the role of understanding older
sister. Jackie misses her Auntie “M” and her
friendship, sound advise and love. Katie, who had trouble
telling the twins apart, remembers a special aunt who
made her laugh. Steve and Rose and Randy and Andrea remember
a playful niece who they will miss terribly.
Mom and I remember a beautiful young lady who was a
delight to be around, who charmed those she met. We remember
a young lady who loved poetry, footnoting poems she especially
loved. She liked to read these poems to her family, even
if she cried when she read them. We remember a gifted
mimic and storyteller who could have been a standup comedian
should she have so chosen. We remember her piano duets
with her sister Alison. Certain songs will forevermore
be special. We remember a great singer who, with her sisters,
would back me up on vocals, doing the doo wop harmonies,
when I played guitar and sang my fifties Rock & Roll
songs. We remember a good writer, but like her father,
a lazy--wait until the last minute-writer. We remember
a daughter who astonished her parents as an older teenager
by sharing with us a completely hidden artistic talent.
How could parents not know that their child had such talent?
She said: “Dad, it is just a drawing of something
I was looking at, not something new.”
Mom and I remember walking behind beautiful twins on
our trips to Mexico and the stir those beautiful twins
would cause. One time in the town of Cancun, not the resort,
we went around a corner and the corner building had at
least one man’s head sticking out of all windows
on three stories. I remember the boys in Guanajuato who
asked me if they could have their pictures taken with
Al and Mel. In my poor Spanish I acted like I misunderstood,
and posed the boys with me. Those muchachos got their
picture. We remember the stories about the commotion they
caused on Bourbon Street during one of their modeling
shoots.
And we remember the modeling career that was just taking
off. Spotted walking to class, Melanie and Alison were
approached to be in the University of Delaware Calendar
in 1999. Then they served as hostesses at a few parties
in Washington and New York City, not really even thinking
of being models. Two years later, Photographer Jim Lewchuk,
who has become a close family friend, was putting together
his own calendar, and after seeing the twins in the Delaware
calendar, he flew them to Puerto Vallarta, Mexico for
the United States Glamour Team Calendar. They got to go
to the New Orleans’ Superdome Car Show and The Fort
Lauderdale Air and Sea Show with Jim to help sell the
calendar. Then, with a lot of help from Jim, their modeling
careers started getting more serious. They shot with various
photographers for those photographers’ websites.
In the summer of 2001, they started working for Anheiser
Bush as Budweiser girls. Later, they were on the cover
of High Times magazine and in a pictorial for FHM magazine.
Next they won a pictorial contest for the Horse Backstreet
Choppers magazine. They became the Horses’ official
Iron Maidens appearing on the cover with a cover story
with many other pictures inside. And before this tragedy,
they were scheduled to travel with the Horse marketing
folks to promote their magazine for all of 2002. They
got to stay at the Playboy mansion and go out with Hugh
Heffner and his girlfriends to trendy clubs in Los Angeles.
They had a great time and got to live like stars while
they were there. A few months after that, they went to
the mansion again for a Mardi Gras party where they got
to meet lots of famous people. Before Melanie’s
death, they were on the list to be automatically invited
to all the Playboy Mansion parties, all costs covered.
They almost got in trouble for hanging out with the mansion
staff with whom they felt more comfortable. It turns out
that whatever else he is, Hugh Heffner is a nice man.
He treated my daughters with respect and sent one of the
first condolence cards from the publishing community to
us after Melanie’s death.
Then, with the help of Jim Lewchuk again, they were
chosen as the spokesmodels, or motor girls, for a new
clothing line called Motor Brands USA. They were scheduled
to tour the country promoting the new line, be on radio
shows, go to all the Ozzfest concerts--whatever that means--and
appear on the Howard Stern show. They were being considered
for an appearance on MTV. The Motor Brands folks made
posters of the twins that are now being distributed with
Alison’s permission as a tribute to Melanie. They
also had their new agent working on an income producing
website called Dupritwins.com which was near completion.
Just after Melanie’s death, they were selected for
a major shoot with another publication with a fee of twenty
five thousand dollars each. Finally, they had been selected
to be the spokespersons for a major consumer brand. They
were still in the process of negotiating financial terms,
but the fees would have been substantial. As their agent
assured them, they were about to be rich and famous.
In a recent letter to me from photographer Jim Lewchuk,
he stated: “Your family has been in the prayers
of my family, and as proven on the Internet, in the hearts
of so many others. It's astonishing how many people Melanie
touched even the ones she never met, didn't know, and
were merely moved by her image. Melanie was an astounding
woman to be sure. “[Your daughters] were on the
verge of tremendous success. Not only was the beauty there,
but everyone marveled at their humbleness. It was such
a unique combination in the industry that they could move
mountains. “I hope Alison goes on with modeling;
many photographers s have already asked and even somewhat
pleaded that she continue. I join in their pleas, and
hope she does so, if she's ever ready in the months to
come.”
So, with her sister Alison, she was being very successful
with a career she loved.
Again, let me thank all of you for coming to this memorial.
Your support means more to Melanie’s family than
you can ever know.